Joannas Diary About JoannaJoannas BlogLinks PageJoannas PhotosTG Captioned ImagesFun stuff

Sunday, July 09, 2006

Trust me, I am a tranny

What is it with some people? They sit down one day and think: ''I know, what the Internet really needs to make it better is some photographs of me with my arse in the air, and maybe a selection of vegetables up there."

It's a strange situation that any tranny Flickr group has to cope with pictures of trannies poking things up there arse, or photos of peoples willies. And so the admins have to continually fight to delete these images. Although some of these girls have now set up their own groups... which in one way is good as they can look at each other I guess.

I know I've written about this before, and was chatting about it again with Becky on MSN last night. I love Flickr. I am almost addicted to Flickr. I can't go too long without checking to see if anyone has commented on my photos - although I don't get too stroppy if people don't comment, nor do I start counting my comments, that's one step away from counting birthday cards to see how much I am loved ;-)

But there's a growing problem with flickr. The first is the photo stealers. Flickr began as a way of sharing your photographs - ones you have taken of yourself. But now a lot of people just use it as an image dump for all their favourite pics. Ones they have lifted off the internet or scanned in from magazines.

I suppose in some ways this is not a major problem. But they don't really attribute the original sources or say its a scan etc. Which is confusing the hell out of the admirers who frequent flickr :-) You get situations where an obvious (to me) famous model has a picture posted by a hairy old man.. but the comments you get are things like ''You look gr8'' ''I would luv 2 meet U'' etc...

It's almost a pavlovian response - see pretty girl, post lecherous comment, without wondering if its a members photo or not.

The other problem is the photoshop trannies. Now I know we all do a little photoshopping of our pics from time to time... tweak the levels, airbrush out a breast form etc. That's not the problem. My most viewed picture has my head on a body with a rather large pair of boobs. But I have always made it clear that thats not me. That the image was done in photoshop and that you shouldnt always believe what you see. And there are enough shots of the ''real'' me so that you can tell what I usually look like.

But you are getting photos where girls are pasting their faces onto other bodies and not being up front about it. Or they are pasting eyes and a mouth.. badly.

This all came about over a specific girl on Flickr. There is something just not right about her photos. Take this one: My Britney Impression. And girls are commenting saying - Wow you look just like Britney.

That's because it is fucking Britney!

You've just pasted a different mouth onto the pic. I couldn't find the exact same pic, it may even have been rotated, but there are too many similarities that show it was from the same photo session at least. ((Update - I've now found it!))

And the others are even worse...

And other people are starting to notice and complain when those pics are posted to a stream like AngelFlickr which tries to keep a modicum of reality - and does not allow headless shots or shots where the face is obscured or modified. Take this shot, I can't quite put my finger exactly on what is wrong with it, but it's just not quite right. It may be that the eyes and mouth have been enhanced, but it may also be that they belong to another face altogether.

And don't get me started on masks.....

If you are going to photoshop your face - then say so. At least tag it as Photoshopped. And say, this is not really me.

I know the whole thing about tranvestism is passing yourself off as someone you are not. But when it reaches the point that you just don't trust any photo that a person puts up as being genuinely them then its a bad thing.

It's just dishonest.

(update - some of these pics have been taken down now, apologies for the broken links)

19 Comments:

  • At July 09, 2006 3:06 PM, Blogger Jane said…

    that shot where "she" is flapping the coat! the only thing that seems to be in focus are the photoshopped eyes and mouth, it looks more like one of the badies out of "Who Killed Roger Rabbit" than a person.

     
  • At July 09, 2006 3:07 PM, Blogger Becky said…

    It's bloody annoying, isn't it? I suppose there's a tendency with trannies for presenting an "illusion", but it's where you draw the line. I have a fairly good gut feeling for what's acceptable photo-manipulation and what's not. Some trannies seem to completely ignore any such line.

     
  • At July 09, 2006 3:38 PM, Blogger Joanna said…

    Found the exact Britney pic now: here

     
  • At July 09, 2006 3:56 PM, Blogger Emilygrae said…

    I would definately have to say that taking somebody else's photo and merely blurring some of it, well it's not quite the same as merely "healing" a blemish or adjusting the lighting for effect, is it?

     
  • At July 09, 2006 4:18 PM, Anonymous Sirena said…

    I've seen this happen for years now. I don't know if it's become epidemic with the advent of Flickr, as I do not have a Flickr account.

    I've called out a few people over the years for using others' pictures or for a bad Photoshop. It really p-sses me off, as well.

    Hello from the States!

     
  • At July 09, 2006 5:57 PM, Blogger Siobhan Curran said…

    > "I know the whole thing about tranvestism is passing yourself off as someone you are not."

    True, but you could possibly argue that transvestism is all about presenting the real you. Maybe.

    DOn't hold me to that though

     
  • At July 09, 2006 6:08 PM, Blogger Joanna said…

    True, but you could possibly argue that transvestism is all about presenting the real you. Maybe.

    True, I know what you mean by that. And yeah, when I dress its sometimes an element of "Me+" and we're using the wig and makeup to enhance ourselves, or bring out another side of ourselves. But we are not hiding behind it.

     
  • At July 09, 2006 6:36 PM, Blogger Siobhan Curran said…

    > But we are not hiding behind it.

    Totally :-) Sorry - I hope I didn't sound like I was defending the Crazy World Of Britney Spears ;-)

    Personally, I think there's such a grey area in terms of Photoshopping pictures. Most of my 'good' ones are all Photoshopped heavily - but mainly just to get a particular effect, rather than compensating, or 'cheating'.

    I can understand, to a certain degree, why someone would 'shop themselves - maybe to complete the fantasy in the easiest way possible. What I can't understand though, is the gullible, sycophantic comments that follow.

    Do they actually not see the fakeness? Or are they just in someway participating in the collaborative fantasy?

     
  • At July 09, 2006 7:48 PM, Blogger Becky said…

    "Most of my 'good' ones are all Photoshopped heavily - but mainly just to get a particular effect, rather than compensating, or 'cheating'."

    Yeah like that one where you made it look like you were on a trampoline! Ridiculous. ;-)

     
  • At July 09, 2006 7:55 PM, Blogger Joanna said…

    they may be photoshopped, but its still you.

    Its not your eyes on someone elses face for example.

     
  • At July 09, 2006 8:12 PM, Anonymous Lucinda Ball said…

    I've noticed how some girls only take photos of the more popular girls which gives the impression that other people don't ever go out! Or is it that everyone else looks shyate?

     
  • At July 09, 2006 8:58 PM, Blogger Becky said…

    ...aaaaand the Britney Lookalike picture disappears.

    Why does that not surprise me? :-)

     
  • At July 09, 2006 9:49 PM, Blogger Joanna said…

    Ah thats a shame Bex.

    Now we work on her other cut and shut jobs....

     
  • At July 09, 2006 10:07 PM, Blogger Siobhan Curran said…

    I gotta say, she deserves a category all to herself that one ;-)

    Now, where can I find stock photo shots of bungee jumping...

     
  • At July 10, 2006 11:38 AM, Blogger Jessica said…

    Perhaps flickr should introduce some kind of block based on exif headers, either no exifs or just not camera exifs. Maybe even just a big warning "This photo does not appear to have come from a digital camera!"

     
  • At July 11, 2006 1:39 AM, Blogger Miss K said…

    Using photoshop to do the sort of stuff you do in a darkroom is very different from using it to collage, which is what that person has done, obviously.

    Like Siobhan, I do "digital darkroom" stuff to my shots in photoshop - adjusting colours, levels, blemish control. Basically bringing out the image I saw when I shot it.

    I do this for almost all my photos, not just those of myself, because for me, it's an integral part of digital photography practice (so I disagree with the EXIF trap, Jessica) - my Nikon shoots a very generic, tonally neutral image in its default setting, just so you have leeway to do darkroom stuff on the image.

    Like many grey areas it's a matter of degree isn't it?

    And who's to say what is nice and what isn't? I remember when Erika Baarova stopped doing the heavily boosted images and started posting more natural ones. We all agreed they were beautiful.

    I think it's only dishonesty that's ugly.

     
  • At July 11, 2006 8:39 AM, Blogger Joanna said…

    I do love some of the heavily processed photos - some of Erikas stuff is amazing.

    Thanks for the comments girls

     
  • At July 11, 2006 9:27 PM, Blogger Karol Cross said…

    Jo, this is fabulous! Thanks for hunting these down.

    Have to say I find it really pathetic when the photos are faked. And I'm not sure I agree with the view that being a trannie is about passing yourself off as something your not. But thats another thread...

    I had a dilema recently as I found someone (non trannie I think) on Flickr who's pasted their face on to photos of models as described here, but then they've heavily photoshopped the pic and the end result is a really cool whole new image which I actually really like in its own right. A lot of effort has obviously gone into the photos, although I'd much prefer it if they where open and honest about what they where doing.

    I think for me thats the key. Fine use PS if you want, but be honest about it. And Miss K's spot on, its all a matter of degree.

     
  • At July 16, 2006 8:56 PM, Anonymous Chrissy Rogers said…

    Never faked a pic in my life, not gonna start now... I only tweak the brightness/ contrast 'cos I never have good enough lighting.

    Image dumping? Guilty as charged, I'm afraid.

     

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home